March Madness: Psych vs. Castle

After weeks of voting, it is down to the final match! Whenever I mentioned the Psych versus Community matchup, people groaned about making the choice, and the buzz made it my most-viewed post ever within a week! 163 brave souls made a decision, and Psych won, 91 to 72. Castle’s victory over Warehouse 13 was easier, as the SyFy show only managed to garner 4 votes.

And now, lovable rogue Nathan Fillion, who really is ruggedly handsome (and who is celebrating his birthday by raising money for charity: water Рdonate now!), along with the beautiful Stana Katic and the rest of the cast of Castle, goes up against the kings of comedy and 80s pop culture, the unstoppable James Roday and the smooth Dul̩ Hill. Shawn and Gus. Castle and Beckett. Which team do you want on your side?

The last battle begins. Which show will emerge victorious? It’s up to you! Vote in the comments below! And be sure to spread the word so your show can win!

Also remember, every comment (one per person per post, but you can comment on any or all of the hundreds of posts on this site) will give you one entry toward the $15 Amazon gift card!

Update: go here to see which show won!

Share this post:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • RSS
  • email
  • Print

631 thoughts on “March Madness: Psych vs. Castle”

  8. OMG these 2 are literally my favorite 2 shows although Psych is my number one show. Castle was my number 1 show til i started watching Psych. UGH they’re booth so awesome but i guess i’ll have to go with Psych

  9. I’ve grown a small yet large obsession with Psych. I love everything about the show. Psych all day, err’day!

  10. Gotta love both these shows, and Nathan Fillion is sublime, but overall,I gotta go with Psych on this one. Just a more addicting show, I guess 🙂

  13. Tough decision but I choose Psych because it is more original than Castle (even if I love Castle too)

  16. “You know that’s right”. Psycho 4 life. Psych. Fist bump to all the other psychos out there.

  20. Oh wow, this is a hard one. I love both these shows. But while the two main characters of both shows are awesome, I like Ryan and Esposito more than Lassie and Juliet, so I guess that means I’m voting for Castle.

  30. Psych all the way! It doesn’t repeat itself as much and it’s way funnier! 🙂

  36. Psych, you know that’s right. I mean the replay value alone has it over Castle!!

  43. I absolutely ADORE both shows, but I’ve been addicted to Psych since the pilot. It took me a while to warm up to Castle. Thus, I’m gonna have to go with my boys, Shawn and Gus, as well as my absolute favorite on-screen and off-screen couple EVER, Shawn&Jules/James&Maggie. My vote definitely goes to PSYCH!!! 😀

Comments are closed.