March Madness: Psych vs. Castle

After weeks of voting, it is down to the final match! Whenever I mentioned the Psych versus Community matchup, people groaned about making the choice, and the buzz made it my most-viewed post ever within a week! 163 brave souls made a decision, and Psych won, 91 to 72. Castle’s victory over Warehouse 13 was easier, as the SyFy show only managed to garner 4 votes.

And now, lovable rogue Nathan Fillion, who really is ruggedly handsome (and who is celebrating his birthday by raising money for charity: water – donate now!), along with the beautiful Stana Katic and the rest of the cast of Castle, goes up against the kings of comedy and 80s pop culture, the unstoppable James Roday and the smooth Dulé Hill. Shawn and Gus. Castle and Beckett. Which team do you want on your side?

The last battle begins. Which show will emerge victorious? It’s up to you! Vote in the comments below! And be sure to spread the word so your show can win!

Also remember, every comment (one per person per post, but you can comment on any or all of the hundreds of posts on this site) will give you one entry toward the $15 Amazon gift card!

Update: go here to see which show won!

Share this post:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati
  • RSS
  • email
  • Print

631 Responses to March Madness: Psych vs. Castle

  1. Moira says:

    I Love Psych more than Castle

  2. JillianLovesFood says:

    It’s hard but I chose Psych over any other detective show on tv!

  3. Jill says:

    This is a no brainer. PSYCH all the way baby. Best show ever, and the funniest. You know that’s right 🙂

  4. Michaela says:


  5. Dana says:

    PSYCH no competition there!

  6. Sara says:

    PSYCH by far. Whattt

  7. Tal says:

    Absolutely without question Castle!!

  8. Beth G says:

    2 of my favorite shows! Augh!
    I actually had to think about this one for a minute BUT when I miss an episode of Castle it may sit unviewed for weeks on my recorder; Psych, no more than a few days. Psych also improves upon repeated viewing, which is why I own Psych DVDs and not Castle.

    Which means I have to go with Psych FTW

  9. Kate says:

    Castle FTW

  10. Jerri says:

    Castle all the way!

  11. CM says:

    CASTLE!!! Best procedural on TV.

  12. Any says:


  13. Leigh says:

    Castle all the way!

  14. M. says:

    CASTLE ftw!!!

  15. Cheyenne says:

    CASTLE !!!!!!!!!!!!

  16. Chiara says:

    Castle!!!!!Best procedural on TV. The only show who really understand that when someone is killed the life of people around is shattered.

  17. Ashlie says:


  18. Leanne says:

    it has to be Castle. No other show has the capacity to both make me laugh constantly, but to also be able to move me to tears. This show has it all; 3 Detectives, 1 writer and a mouthy M.E who I adore (Lanie ftw).

  19. Jessi says:


  20. Jessica says:

    Castle and Beckett, DUH!

  21. Almina says:

    Castle is the best show on TV since ever!

  22. harleen says:

    castle !!! obviously !

  23. Chiara says:

    Castle, of course!

  24. Rhiannon says:

    CASTLE always 😉 There’s no team like Caskett!

  25. Dale says:


  26. Anke says:


  27. Caroline says:


  28. Lau says:

    Castle of course =D

  29. Caitlin says:

    Castle all the way!!!!!!!!!

  30. Alice says:


  31. Lisa says:

    Castle is the best

  32. Jenn says:

    While I enjoy Psych, I adore and obsess over Castle. My vote is CASTLE.

  33. Caskett91911 says:

    Castle of course! What other show can make you cry, laugh, gasp, and die during every episode? Yeah….in MilMar we trust 🙂

  34. Kie says:


  35. Jim says:


  36. Nelly says:


  37. Karen says:

    Not even a contest… Castle of course! Castle FTW!

  38. Jenny says:

    My vote has to go to Castle, even though I love both shows!

  39. mia says:


  40. Elizabeth says:


  41. vicmag says:

    i vote for CASTLE!!!!

  42. becky says:


  43. amor says:

    CASTLE of course!!!

  44. Angel says:

    Most definitly Castle!!!! OMG Team Caskett all the way! Castle FTW Always… 🙂

  45. jove says:

    its CASTLE! of course! it has everything you want!!!

  46. amelia says:

    CASTLE! im so hooked to this duo! go CASKET

  47. Mette says:

    CASTLE!!! FTW.

  48. Vette says:

    Castle! Always better! Its witty and fun to watch, cant miss an episode! Love it too much! Stana & Nathan r better too! CASTLE! Bring on season 5!

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: suv | Thanks to toyota suv, infiniti suv and lexus suv