A total of 32 duos (all pictured above) were eliminated during round one. Some very nearly won: Friends’ Chandler and Joey lost by only two votes to Angela and Hodgins from Bones. With others, the vote was more decisive. Harvey and Mike from Suits won the highest percentage of votes in any round one matchup (96%), thanks to tweets from cast, the show’s official Twitter, and more than 50 fans (they were actually losing to Mork and Mindy by a few votes well into the final day). That poll also had the most votes cast in a round one matchup as well. The second most decisive vote was Merlin and Arthur’s victory over Nikita and Michael (93% to 7%), primarily due to fans sharing on Tumblr.
All of that clearly shows that your sharing efforts can make a HUGE difference in polls like these! So as round two continues, be sure to keep sharing! Below is a full list of round one eliminations (or you can view the updated chart here). Which duos do you think should have gone on to round two?
Zane and Jo from Eureka lost to Marshall and Lily from How I Met Your Mother
Oscar and Felix from The Odd Couple lost to Buffy and Spike from Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Kensi and Deeks from NCIS: Los Angeles lost to Kirk and Spock from Star Trek
McGarrett and Danno from Hawaii Five-O lost to Hawkeye and BJ from M*A*S*H
JD and Turk from Scrubs lost to Rizzoli and Isles from Rizzoli & Isles
Mozzie and Elizabeth from White Collar lost to Booth and Brennan from Bones
Casey and Morgan from Chuck lost to The Doctor and Donna from Doctor Who
Wes and Travis from Common Law lost to Veronica and Logan from Veronica Mars
Jerry and George from Seinfeld lost to Walter and Leo from The Finder
Gibbs and Abby from NCIS lost to Peter and Neal from White Collar
Hank and Evan from Royal Pains lost to Castle and Beckett from Castle
Chandler and Joey from Friends lost to Angela and Hodgins from Bones
Nikita and Michael from Nikita lost to Merlin and Arthur from Merlin
Max and Caroline from 2 Broke Girls lost to Andy and Barney from The Andy Griffith Show
Klink and Schultz from Hogan’s Heroes lost to Cagney and Lacey from Cagney & Lacey
Sherlock and Watson from Sherlock lost to Dean and Sam from Supernatural
Hardison and Eliot from Leverage lost to Brenda and Fritz from The Closer
Nick and Monroe from Grimm lost to Tony and Ziva from NCIS
Liz and Jack from 30 Rock lost to David and Maddie from Moonlighting
Peter and Olivia from Fringe lost to Leonard and Sheldon from The Big Bang Theory
Laverne and Shirley from Laverne & Shirley lost to House and Wilson from House
Jane and Lisbon from The Mentalist lost to Sam and Callen from NCIS: Los Angeles
Reese and Finch from Person of Interest lost to Lucy and Ethel from I Love Lucy
Benson and Stabler from Law and Order: SVU lost to Chuck and Sarah from Chuck
Annie and Auggie from Covert Affairs lost to Pete and Myka from Warehouse 13
Will and Carlton from The Fresh Prince of Bel Air lost to Nate and Sophie from Leverage
Howard and Raj from The Big Bang Theory lost to Claudia and Jinks from Warehouse 13
Robin and Much from Robin Hood lost to Angel and Cordelia from Angel
Meredith and Derek from Grey’s Anatomy lost to Shawn and Gus from Psych
Mulder and Scully from The X-Files lost to Troy and Abed from Community
Mork and Mindy from Mork & Mindy lost to Harvey and Mike from Suits
Jim and Dwight from The Office lost to Lorelai and Rory from Gilmore Girls
One more interesting note – out of the 8 shows with 2 duos in the competition, only two of the shows (Bones and Warehouse 13) had both duos make it to round two. The other 6 had one duo make it, and one duo not. Both sets of duos from the same show will face each other before the final (if they make it through the previous rounds victorious), so it’s not possible for two duos from the same show to be in the final match. It is possible (though not probable) for the only actor in multiple duos (David Boreanaz, as Booth and Angel) to face himself in the final.
I can’t believe Mulder and Scully lost in the 1st round! Sherlock and Watson also should’ve gone through, but Supernatural usually wins every poll it’s nominated in, so that was a done deal.
We worked hard on it and I would have loved to see Hardison and Eliot from Leverage to go on to round two. They really deserved it!!!